Consignment Store Insider

Sunny + Olive Co

Consignment store in Milton, Wisconsin

Where
Milton, WI
Right now
Opens 10 AM

Consignor information

We found 14 of 25 terms on this store's website. Check with the store before bringing items in.

Contract terms

What the store pays a consignor, and on what schedule. Where a store also buys outright, these describe the consignment side only.

Contract length
60 days
Payout method
in-store credit, cash, or venmo
Payout timing
as they sell
Unsold items
Because of our growth, we no longer pull unsold items for return. You are always welcome to stop in and pick up your unsold items before the end of their selling period.

Not disclosed: consignor split, markdown schedule, store credit bonus.

What they accept

Stores are selective — brand tiers, condition standards and seasonal windows are normal, and being turned down once does not mean a store is closed to you.

Categories accepted
Men’s and women’s clothing (all sizes)
Brand tier
Mall brands (Abercrombie, Aritzia, Free People, Zara, etc.), Boutique brands
Condition standard
Clean and freshly laundered, In excellent condition (no stains, holes, pilling, or excessive wear)
Seasonal rules
Bring in-season items for the best chance of acceptance
Not accepted
Fast fashion basics (Shein, Temu, etc.), Target, Old Navy, Kohls, Walmart, Older styles that feel dated, Worn, faded, or damaged items, Items with pet hair, odors, or heavy fragrance, Formalwear or business professional pieces (unless currently trending), Undergarments

Getting started & intake

The practical details — when to turn up, what to bring, and how long a decision takes.

Intake method
walk-in
Intake days & hours
Tuesday through Sunday from 10 AM to 5 PM
Account setup required
Yes
Review method
We’ll take about 10–15 minutes to sift, sort, and swoon over your stuff
Turnaround
same day

Not disclosed: minimum items, items per visit, account fee, id required.

Where to watch for new arrivals

Stock turns over constantly and most of it is one of a kind. These are the places this store shows what has just come in.

Shipping & delivery

Whether the store can get an item to you, or move a large piece for you.

This store has not published its shipping and delivery details.

Other consignment stores in Milton